Monday, October 3, 2011

Recipe #1 - Nut Butter Balls (cookies)




I chose this recipe mostly because I had all the ingredients - especially the ground almonds (ground blanched almonds for my failure Jewish New Year dessert).  I cut the recipe in half due to limitations of ingredients and also in case the recipe didn't work, I didn't want 2 dozen cookies wasted.

I let the butter get soft before creaming it with the sugar.  I grabbed the rest of my ingredients and realized that of course I had no more almond extract (I avoid imitation flavoring whenever possible).  I threw on my shoes and ran down the stairs, being thankful that New York City is good for one major thing - I live across the street from a grocery store.  I came back to finish the cookies and found myself staring at the recipe confused as to how this will work with no eggs.  I began to think that I was reading something wrong, of course there are eggs, but no matter how much I stared at the recipe, the fact that there were no eggs, and basically no moisture to make the batter stick together, was not going to change.   I put in all the butter because the recipe was so dry I couldn't eliminate anything wet.

The result was a crumbly mess.  Instead of crying, I stuck my hands in the bowl and bunched the crumbly batter as much as possible, grabbed my plastic wrap, and threw the balled up "dough" in the fridge, unsure of whether or not the first recipe I complete from my mission of 1954 recipes, was going to be awful.

I came home hours later and immediately turned on my oven and took the ball of dough out of the fridge.  After 15 minutes I decided I needed to somehow break the dough apart to form cookie balls.  This task was not easy to put it mildly.  The dough was incredibly hard and still crumbly and took all my strength to keep the balls together and somewhat shaped to go into the oven.    I managed to make all the dough into smaller balls and threw the pan in the oven with the timer on 13 minutes.   After 10 minutes I checked the oven and was unsure what was happening.  The balls were getting softer but were still white, I turned one of the balls over to the other side and noticed the bottom of it was brown - they were beginning to resemble biscuits.... I decided to reach in and turn all the balls over so that at least each end was brown. 

Finally I took the cookies out of the oven, after about 16 minutes or so.   I put the powdered sugar in a bowl and burned my hands placing the nut balls one at a time into the sugar and rolling them around, being careful so that they didn't come apart and crumble into the sugar (which of course 2 of them did, but I worked them back together).   I put them on the cooling rack with tinfoil underneath to catch any loose sugar.

Still unsure of how they were going to taste and what was going to happen with my great idea to bake all of my grandma's recipes from 1954...I tasted a nut ball.  The result was something a bit crumbly, definitely messy...but wait, kind of delicious.   At that moment my boyfriend walked in the door and I made him eat the other half of my cookie and waited to see his response.

The verdict - he decided he really needed a second cookie before having my delicious butternut squash ravioli dinner.

They remind me of shortbread in the way they are hard and crumbly and a bit buttery.  

Recipe #1 - Nut Butter Balls = totally delicious - Good Work Grandma!  I'm sorry I ever doubted you

If you are going to make these - please don't get discouraged, the result is actually delicious and although they seem like a disaster throughout the entire process, I would feel confident bringing these to a dinner party, but I also feel even better about them sitting in my kitchen greeting me every night after work until they are all devoured into my belly.

3 comments:

  1. Good on you!
    I think I remember these cookies very well. They were some of my favorites. My recollection is of crumbly,nutty, airylight, buttery sweetness that burst apart in my mouth, leaving the powdered sugar sticking clammily to the roof. Your Grandma made them small, so I probably popped them in whole. One reason was because they were small. The other was cause I knew they'd fall apart if I tempted to bite into them and I'd be left with crumbs on the table, and that powdered sugar clammily sticking to my fingers instead of the roof of my mouth, where it belonged.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is such a cool project! Did you know your grandma had published a book before last week?!?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm the lucky one who gets to taste these crumbly nut wonders! I love shortbread and I love almonds and Powdered Sugar is basically my best friend. Thus - I'm a big fan of these Butter Balls!

    ReplyDelete